Society

A rotten acacia tree fell on a Volkswagen in Mykolaiv: court orders municipal workers to pay

Broken glass and damaged bodywork: how much will municipal workers pay the car’s owner?

Цей матеріал також доступний:

The owner of a Volkswagen Golf will receive 116,745 hryvnias from the municipal enterprise “Mykolaiv Parks.” The decision was made by the Zavodskyi District Court of Mykolaiv after a branch from a black locust tree fell onto the parked car. This is stated in the court’s ruling dated November 12, 2026, in case No. 487/9298/25.

The incident occurred on July 24. The car was parked between a residential building and a shop. The falling branch shattered the windshield and the rear right door window, dented the hood, and scratched the roof. During an inspection of the scene, law enforcement officers found that the black locust branch was rotten inside. The owner filed a lawsuit against the municipal enterprise “Mykolaiv Parks”. Initially, she sought 112,900 hryvnias in material damages and 10,000 hryvnias in compensation for moral damages.

The enterprise contested the claims. Its representative argued that no external signs of danger had been found during inspections of the trees and that the branch had green leaves. According to the enterprise, the internal rot could only have been noticed after the branch fell.

During the proceedings, the court ordered an automotive valuation expert examination. According to its findings, repairing the car would cost more than 143,000 hryvnias. The plaintiff later reduced her claim for material damages to 95,622 hryvnias and withdrew her claim for moral damages. On November 2, the representative of “Mykolaiv Parks” filed a statement admitting the claim and agreeing to pay the amount sought.

The court established that the land where the black locust grew was municipally owned and that the municipal enterprise was responsible for maintaining the greenery there. The court also considered the regulations on maintaining green spaces, which require hazardous trees to be identified, including those showing signs of a rotten core. Ultimately, the court granted the claim. “Mykolaiv Parks” must pay the car owner 95,622 hryvnias in material damages, plus 21,123 hryvnias for the damage assessment, expert examination, and court fee. The total amount awarded is 116,745 hryvnias.

We previously reported:

Читайте новини першими

Связанные статьи

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button